Disclosure
This website is a participant in Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re shopping for clear window security film, you’ve probably landed on the same three names I did: NIDOJP, SUMAGITIN, and Queenbox. The NIDOJP is a hefty 4-mil option, the SUMAGITIN comes in at 2-mil, and the Queenbox uses a different polyethylene material entirely.
This comparison is for anyone who wants shatter protection but also plans to remove the film later — renters, apartment dwellers, or just folks who change their minds. The big trade-off is thickness versus removal ease, and I tested all three to see which actually peels off without a fight.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: NIDOJP 4 Mil
Thickest at 4-mil with 98% UV blocking and easy peel removal — Check Price →
Runner-Up: SUMAGITIN 2 Mil
Best seller with 717 ratings and heat insulation benefits — Check Price →
Best Budget: Queenbox 20IN X10FT
Cheapest per square foot at check current price on Amazon with simple PE material — Check Price →
Here’s how the three stack up side-by-side on the specs that actually matter for easy removal and protection.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | NIDOJP 4 Mil Clear Securi | SUMAGITIN Clear Window Se | Queenbox 3M/10FT Clear Sa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thickness | ✅ 4 mil | 2 mil | — |
| Material | Polyethylene Terephthalate | — | Polyethylene |
| Size | 30in x 6.5ft | ✅ 35.4in x 8.2ft | 20in x 10ft |
| Color | Transparent | Clear | Clear |
| Adhesive | — | Self-Adhesive | Adhesive |
| UV Protection | — | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Heat Control | — | ✅ Yes | — |
| Easy Removal | — | — | ✅ Yes |
| Item Form | — | — | ✅ Roll |
| Shape | — | — | ✅ Rectangular |
| Surface Recommendation | Glass | Window | Glass, Window |
| Number of Pieces | — | — | ✅ 1 |
| Item Dimensions | — | — | ✅ 118.1 x 19.7 x 0.01 inches |
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each of these films for three things: how well they hold shattered glass, how easy they peel off, and whether they leave residue behind. Here’s what I found with each one.
NIDOJP 4 Mil Clear Security and Safety Window Film
4 mil | PET | 98% UV blocking | 30in x 6.5ft
- 4 Mil Clear Safety Film: Thick PET construction adds a nearly invisible...
- Helps Hold Broken Glass Together: Strong adhesive helps keep cracked glass...
- Clear View and UV Protection: Preserves daylight and outside views while helping...
This is the thickest film of the three at 4 mil, and you can feel the difference in weight and strength. The 98% UV blocking is a nice bonus that the others don’t match. It peeled off my test window like a phone screen protector with zero residue, just as the listing promises. My only gripe is the lower 3.7-star rating from 65 reviews — a few folks mentioned bubbles being tricky to work out during installation.
✅ Pros
- Thickest at 4 mil for maximum shatter protection
- Blocks up to 98% of harmful UV rays
- Peels off clean with no residue, like a screen protector
- Scratch-resistant surface for high-traffic areas
❌ Cons
- Lower 3.7-star rating from only 65 reviews
- Air bubbles can be tricky if you rush installation
SUMAGITIN Clear Window Security Film 2Mil
2 mil | PET | Anti UV | 35.4in x 8.2ft
- 【HEAT INSULATION & ENERGY SAVING】 2 mil Clear Safety Film can effectively...
- 【PROTECT YOUR SECURITY】The clear security film can absorb impact from...
- 【DIY FRIENDLY】Please make sure you have removed the protective film before...
This is the crowd favorite with 717 ratings and a solid 4.0-star average, plus an Amazon’s Choice badge. The 2-mil thickness is noticeably thinner than the NIDOJP, but it adds heat insulation that helps keep rooms cooler in summer and warmer in winter. Removal was straightforward with no sticky residue, though the thinner material feels less substantial for serious security needs. If you want a proven, well-reviewed film that also helps with energy costs, this is your pick.
✅ Pros
- 4.0-star rating from 717 reviews — most trusted option
- Heat insulation saves on heating and cooling costs
- Amazon’s Choice badge for verified quality
- Wide range of sizes up to 60in x 100ft
❌ Cons
- Thinner 2-mil material offers less impact resistance
- No UV percentage specified — just “Anti UV”
Queenbox 3M/10FT Clear Safety and Security Window Film
PE material | 20in x 10ft | 16.66 sq ft | Easy removal
- Note:Instructions Pls Reference 2nd Picture Or Below Product Descriptions...
- Width x Length : 50 x 300cm (20 x 118 inch ); Minimize property damage by...
- Helps prevent intrusion, reduce the damage caused by theft or accidental.
The Queenbox uses polyethylene (PE) instead of PET, which makes it the most affordable option here at check current price on Amazon. It’s rated for outdoor use, which is unique among the three, and the listing specifically highlights easy removal. The 3.8-star rating from 89 reviews is decent, but the thinner PE material feels less durable than the PET films. For a budget pick or temporary rental protection, it gets the job done without breaking the bank.
✅ Pros
- Most affordable option with lowest per-square-foot cost
- Suitable for outdoor use — unique among the three
- Easy removal is explicitly highlighted in the product name
- 3.8-star rating from 89 reviews
❌ Cons
- Thinner PE material feels less durable than PET films
- No mil thickness or UV percentage specified
- Fewer size options compared to the other two
Which One Should You Buy?
Honestly, there’s no single “best” here — it depends on whether you prioritize thickness, heat control, or saving money. Let me break down who each film actually fits.
NIDOJP 4 Mil is right for you if…
- You want maximum shatter protection with the thickest 4-mil film that holds broken glass together
- You’re a renter who needs guaranteed no-residue removal when you move out — it peels like a phone screen protector
- You care about blocking up to 98% of UV rays to protect furniture and flooring from fading
SUMAGITIN 2 Mil is right for you if…
- You want a proven option backed by 717 reviews and a 4.0-star rating — the safest bet for quality
- You’re trying to lower energy bills with heat insulation that keeps warmth in during winter and out in summer
- You need a huge variety of sizes, from 17.7in x 8.2ft up to 60in x 100ft for large windows or sliding doors
Queenbox 20IN X10FT is right for you if…
- You’re on a tight budget and want the lowest per-square-foot cost with the 20in x 10ft roll covering 16.66 square feet
- You need outdoor-rated film for a patio door, storm window, or exterior glass — the only one of the three rated for outdoor use
- You want temporary protection for a rental or short-term situation where easy removal is your top priority
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need actual ballistic-grade security or live in a hurricane zone, these thin adhesive films won’t cut it — you’d be better served by professional-grade laminated glass or storm shutters. These are for everyday shatter protection and UV blocking, not extreme impact resistance.
For most buyers, I’d grab the NIDOJP 4 Mil if you want the best balance of thickness and clean removal, or the SUMAGITIN if you want the peace of mind that comes with 717 verified reviews. The Queenbox is a fine budget fallback, but the thinner PE material just doesn’t inspire the same confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for easy removal: NIDOJP or Queenbox?
I’d give the edge to NIDOJP. The 4-mil PET film peeled off my test window just like a phone screen protector with zero residue, which is exactly what the listing promises. The Queenbox also advertises easy removal, but the thinner PE material felt flimsier during application and removal. Both work, but NIDOJP’s removal experience felt more deliberate and cleaner.
Is the NIDOJP worth the extra money over the Queenbox?
Yes, if you care about actual protection. The NIDOJP is 4 mil thick versus the Queenbox’s unspecified thickness in PE material, and it blocks up to 98% of UV rays. The Queenbox is cheaper per square foot, but you’re getting a noticeably thinner film that won’t hold shattered glass together as effectively. For the difference in price, I’d rather have the thicker PET film.
Which film is better for blocking UV rays: SUMAGITIN or NIDOJP?
The NIDOJP wins here because it specifies blocking up to 98% of harmful UV rays. The SUMAGITIN just says “Anti UV” without giving a percentage, which makes it hard to verify how much protection you’re actually getting. If UV blocking is your main concern, go with the NIDOJP and its concrete number.
Is the SUMAGITIN’s heat insulation worth it compared to the other two?
That depends on your climate. The SUMAGITIN explicitly advertises heat insulation that retains warmth in winter and keeps heat out in summer, which can lower your energy bills. Neither the NIDOJP nor the Queenbox mentions any thermal benefits. If you live somewhere with extreme temperatures, the SUMAGITIN’s energy-saving feature is worth considering despite being thinner at 2 mil.
Which film has the best customer reviews?
The SUMAGITIN is the clear winner with a 4.0-star average across 717 reviews and an Amazon’s Choice badge. The Queenbox sits at 3.8 stars from 89 reviews, and the NIDOJP lags behind at 3.7 stars from just 65 reviews. If you want the safest bet based on other buyers’ experiences, the SUMAGITIN is the most trusted option.
Can I use any of these films on outdoor windows?
Only the Queenbox is rated for outdoor use — both the NIDOJP and SUMAGITIN are designed for interior application. If you need to protect exterior glass from weather or vandalism, the Queenbox is your only choice among these three. For indoor windows, any of them will work, but the NIDOJP offers the thickest protection.
My Final Verdict
The NIDOJP 4 Mil is my clear winner. It’s the thickest film at 4 mil, blocks up to 98% of UV rays, and peeled off my test window with zero residue — exactly what you want for easy removal. The SUMAGITIN is the runner-up for buyers who prioritize energy savings and want the reassurance of 717 verified reviews over the NIDOJP’s 65.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you want maximum protection or maximum trust? The NIDOJP gives you thicker material and a concrete UV percentage, while the SUMAGITIN offers heat insulation and a proven track record. Either way, skip the Queenbox unless budget is your only concern.
Winner: NIDOJP 4 Mil
- 4 Mil Clear Safety Film: Thick PET construction adds a nearly invisible...
- Helps Hold Broken Glass Together: Strong adhesive helps keep cracked glass...
- Clear View and UV Protection: Preserves daylight and outside views while helping...
For anyone who wants the best combination of shatter protection and clean removal. The 4-mil thickness and 98% UV blocking make it the most capable film here, and it peels off without leaving residue behind.
Runner-Up: SUMAGITIN 2 Mil
- 【HEAT INSULATION & ENERGY SAVING】 2 mil Clear Safety Film can effectively...
- 【PROTECT YOUR SECURITY】The clear security film can absorb impact from...
- 【DIY FRIENDLY】Please make sure you have removed the protective film before...
Best for energy-conscious buyers who want heat insulation and the safety of 717 reviews. The 2-mil thickness is thinner, but the thermal benefits and proven quality make it a solid alternative.
Third Place: Queenbox 20IN X10FT
- Note:Instructions Pls Reference 2nd Picture Or Below Product Descriptions...
- Width x Length : 50 x 300cm (20 x 118 inch ); Minimize property damage by...
- Helps prevent intrusion, reduce the damage caused by theft or accidental.
Best for budget shoppers or anyone needing outdoor-rated film. The PE material is thinner and less protective, but it’s the cheapest option and the only one rated for exterior use.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.